New Comet Origins Idea Adds New Problems | The Institute for Creation Research

New Comet Origins Idea Adds New Problems

Comets continue to confound cosmologists, who often assert that the small celestial bodies came from the “Oort Cloud,” a theoretical group of planetary leftovers that supposedly orbits the solar system.

But “no confirmed direct observations of the Oort Cloud have been made,” despite long and careful searches. And one cosmologist noted that the “standard model can’t produce anywhere near the number of comets we see.”1 So, a team of researchers recently proposed an addition to the theory, though it has no evidence supporting it either.

Even if it existed, mathematical models indicate that “the numbers just don’t add up” in favor of the Oort Cloud supplying the comets that are observed. So, Southwest Research Institute’s Hal Levison described to NASA Science News a scenario in which earth’s sun used to be very near to stars within its cluster. Thus, “the stars were close enough together to pull comets away from each other via gravity.”1

Levison theorized that since comets have “highly eccentric long-period orbits that take them far from our Sun…they had to have formed close to other stars and then been hijacked here.”1 One unsolved question about comet origins that this new idea attempts to answer is why they travel on such improbable tracks, as though they had been placed in unusual orbits on purpose.

If gravity is the only force that influenced comet motion, however, then comets should have either crashed into the sun or escaped its pull and been spun straight out into space. The chances of a random placement of a comet into its eccentric orbit are tiny, a mathematical improbability multiplied by each additional comet that follows the same pattern. Earth’s solar system has 3,044 designated comets.2

Thus, Levison and his colleagues propose that the sun stole comets from an imaginary ancient comet supply. But if so, why did the other stars not attract their fair share? Did they not also have gravity? In any case, these gravitational interactions supposedly then produced the solar system comets and Oort Cloud. But neither the Oort Cloud nor this “hijacking” of comets from other stars has been observed.

In sum, this solar gravity capture scenario still has no remotely probable mechanism to supply the number, trajectory, or temporality of comets. In fact, it just adds another unbelievable story onto an older one. The evidence points to comets, like stars and galaxies, having been put in place on purpose recently, just like Genesis records.3

References

  1. Coulter, D. The Sun Steals Comets from Other Stars. NASA Science News. Posted on science.nasa.gov November 23, 2010, accessed December 2, 2010.
  2. Johnston, W. R. Known populations of solar system objects: May 2010. Johnston’s Archive Fact sheet. Posted on johnstonsarchive.net June 19, 2010, accessed December 7, 2010. 
  3. Genesis 1:16.

Image credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech

* Mr. Thomas is Science Writer at the Institute for Creation Research.

Article posted on December 9, 2010.

The Latest
NEWS
Destruction of Plants Fits Flood Narrative
A recent study has found that the destruction of plants preceded the destruction of many forms of animal life in the rock record.1 This is exactly...

NEWS
No Evidence T. rex Hatchlings Had Feathers
The recent discovery of a tiny tyrannosaur jaw bone fragment and a claw has some scientists again pushing dinosaurs as birds.1 But is there...

NEWS
Inside March 2021 Acts & Facts
Why does ICR uphold the clarity of Scripture? How do we know that canyons were formed by the Genesis Flood? How do fossilized fish confirm biblical...

DAYS OF PRAISE DEVOTIONALS
Spring 2021
...

ACTS & FACTS
Creation Kids: Human Hands
You’re never too young to be a creation scientist! Kids, discover fun facts about God’s creation with ICR’s special Creation Kids learning...

ACTS & FACTS
Dross and Dilution
The first of seven great signs of Jesus’ deity recorded in John’s gospel is the wedding in Cana of Galilee (John 2:1-11). By the time Jesus...

APOLOGETICS
Do the Unpersuaded Have Enough Proof?
At a local Bible conference, a respected seminary professor unintentionally contradicted the apostle Paul. During the Q&A session, he opined that...

ACTS & FACTS
Gunnison's Black Canyon: The Flood Solves Mysterious Missing...
Brian Thomas, Ph.D., and Tim Clarey, Ph.D. The Gunnison River winds westward from the Colorado Rocky Mountains through dry and dramatic landscapes....

ACTS & FACTS
Do We See Complex Design in Mosquito Eggs?
Mosquitoes hatch from tiny eggs and spend a few days filter-feeding on things like bacteria, pollen, and algae. They molt three times as they grow,...

ACTS & FACTS
A Texas-Size Spider Mystery
The delightfully creepy spider belongs to a class called Arachnida—which is distinct from the “bug” class Insecta. Not surprisingly,...