Black Rocks Red-Flag Uniformitarian Flaws | The Institute for Creation Research

Black Rocks Red-Flag Uniformitarian Flaws

Red flags traditionally act as warning signals. In this case of a surprising rock discovery in West Virginia the flag is black rather than red, but the results are the same. Geologist Callan Bentley recently blogged about another problem with the uniformitarian model.1 As he and Alan Pitts examined the Hampshire Formation in eastern West Virginia, they came across an unexpected phenomenon: a 16-foot black shale and lime layer. The problem? This new layer is sandwiched smack-dab within a 2000-foot-thick pile of red-rock strata that has been labeled by secularists as continental river, delta, and floodplain deposits.

The finding bewildered the researchers. On closer examination, they found brachiopod (lamp shell) and gastropod (snail) fossils indicative of an ocean source. What they thought was a thick pile of exclusively land-derived sediments turned out to contain concrete evidence of ocean-derived sediments. Bentley wrote, "Wow—this surprised us. Neither of us thought the Hampshire Formation had any marine strata within it."1

And the black color was also baffling. Uniformitarian theories usually interpret dark-gray and black sediments as having formed in a restricted marine environment with an abundance of preserved organic material and, therefore, low oxygen levels.2

Bentley arrived at two possible conclusions. Either they misidentified the rocks as being part of the Hampshire Formation, or this was a discovery of "a new marine portion of a previously-thought-to-be- terrestrial-only geologic unit."1

If the latter conclusion is true, according to Bentley this ocean-derived layer "seems to have come on pretty suddenly," appearing abruptly and disappearing upward just as fast.1

If the former conclusion is the best explanation and this rock bed comprises a different formation, it still doesn't eliminate the problem of discovering a marine deposit embedded within a unit traditionally interpreted as terrestrial. Secularists nearly always considered beds surrounding abundant black shale as non-marine deposits.2

Something is definitely wrong with the uniformitarian story—why else would scientists be so surprised by the black rock and marine fossils? Could it be that all these strata—the red and black rocks—are deposits from the great Flood? This interpretation eliminates the mystery of how marine fossils are found sandwiched in between red sands and shale. It also solves the mystery of the black, organic-rich shale.

Rapid deposition during the Flood would have preserved ample organic material to give a black coloration to the rocks. There is no need to call on special, restricted, low-oxygen conditions to explain the dark color. Organic debris was merely buried within the Flood sediments along with the fossil shelled animals.

A Flood origin for the sediments accounts for the rock types we observe much better than secular models. Creationists don't have to fabricate tales of the sea level rising and then draining off the land suddenly, over and over. We just recognize it happened once, in a catastrophic way, about 4,500 years ago.

References

  1. Bentley, C. A marine incursion in the Hampshire Formation? Mountain Beltway blog. Posted on blogs.agu.org February 17, 2014, accessed March 12, 2014, emphasis in original.
  2. Boggs, S., Jr. 2006. Principles of Sedimentology and Stratigraphy, 4th ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson/Prentice Hall.

Image credit: Copyright © 2014 American Geophysical Union. Adapted for use in accordance with federal copyright (fair use doctrine) law. Usage by ICR does not imply endorsement of copyright holders.

*Dr. Clarey is Research Associate at the Institute for Creation Research and received his Ph.D. in geology from Western Michigan University.

Article posted on March 12, 2014.

The Latest
NEWS
Human Genome 20th Anniversary—Junk DNA Hits the Trash
The first rough drafts of the human genome were reported in 2001 (one in the private sector and one in the public sector).1-2 Since then, after...

NEWS
Bacterial Proteins Use Quantum Mechanics
Researchers have found a dimmer switch inside a protein. It tunes the protein’s configuration to take advantage of quantum mechanics during photosynthesis....

NEWS
Dr. Bill Cooper, ICR’s Adjunct Professor, Now in Glory
Earlier last month on March the 9th, Dr. William R. Cooper, ICR’s Master Faculty (known to ICR-SOBA’s faculty as “Dr. Bill” since...

NEWS
Inside April 2021 Acts & Facts
How will ICR expand biblical creation education this year? How do fossilized fish and land creatures confirm Genesis history? Does recent research support...

ACTS & FACTS
Creation Kids: Bees
You’re never too young to be a creation scientist! Kids, discover fun facts about God’s creation with ICR’s special Creation Kids learning...

ACTS & FACTS
Pleasure in Our Purpose
Eric Liddell was one of the most famous athletes of the 20th century and perhaps the greatest that Scotland ever produced. An international rugby player,...

APOLOGETICS
Beware Sinkholes and Other Failing Foundations
The sudden falling of some Christian schools can be compared to tiankengs, the geological term used for sinkholes that are at least 300 feet deep.1,2...

ACTS & FACTS
The Painted Desert: Fossils in Flooded Mud Flats
Brian Thomas, Ph.D., and Tim Clarey, Ph.D. The Painted Desert stretches across 120 miles of northern Arizona. Its sedimentary rocks show bright...

ACTS & FACTS
Does Recent Research Support Human Evolution?
In 1997, the Institute for Creation Research ran an Acts & Facts article on the lack of compelling evidence regarding our supposed evolution from...

ACTS & FACTS
Building a Perfectly Optimal Flying Machine
For thousands of years, people have dreamed of flying because they witnessed birds and knew it was possible. Inspired by a study of birds, the Wright...