Skeptics Analyze Original Tissues with Lousy Logic | The Institute for Creation Research
Skeptics Analyze Original Tissues with Lousy Logic

The scientific literature contains over 100 examples of original biomaterials in fossils.1 These include a few decades’ worth of reports, using at least a few dozen independent techniques to target specific vertebrate biochemicals—such as the hardy protein collagen.

One team of skeptics recently published a report trying to disprove the existence of collagen in supposedly ancient bone. They made the case that they found no collagen in their one dinosaur bone, and because they found microbes in it, therefore all the other claims of Cretaceous collagen are false. All that published work from hundreds of expert researchers around the world supposedly mistook modern microbes for ancient proteins.2 Three shortcomings in this report leave short-lived collagen perfectly intact inside dinosaur bones. It also leaves intact the enormous weight that fossil proteins force evolutionary time to shoulder.

The first shortcoming is lousy logic. Even non-specialists can see that just because one fossil bone has no collagen, it doesn’t mean others have none. Logicians call this the “hasty generalization fallacy.” It happens when we assume that just a few particulars in one instance describe the whole field in general. Even if their fossil bone had no collagen, so what? That could just mean that all the collagen in their bone decayed or degraded over the thousands of years it has been sitting underground since the Flood. Possibly most fossils have no collagen—but that doesn’t mean all do not, or cannot, have it.

Second, the study group used evolutionary logic in place of observational science. The eLife study authors wrote, “Reports of dinosaur protein and complex organic structure preservation are problematic for several reasons. Firstly, it remains unclear how such organics would be preserved for tens of millions of years.”2

Their circular logic looks like this:

1. Dinosaur fossils formed millions of years ago.
2. Collagen cannot last millions of years.
3. Therefore, dinosaur fossils cannot contain collagen.

Next,

1. Dinosaur fossils cannot contain collagen.
2. Reports show collagen in dinosaur fossils.
3. Therefore, reports must show contamination, not collagen.

The conclusions follow those premises, but what if the first premise is the very question at stake? The team merely assumed that dinosaur fossils cannot contain collagen by assuming that the bones are tens of millions of year old. They did not demonstrate those millions of years. Ultimately, they conclude contamination not because they found any evidence of contamination in the dozens of published reports, but merely on the basis of a time assumption.

Better logic follows this flow:

1. Collagen cannot last millions of years.
2. Numerous reports show collagen in dinosaur fossils.
3. Therefore, reports show that dinosaur fossils did not last millions of years.

Last, the eLife study concluded that tissues in fossils actually come from microbe-made biofilms (flimsy films that bacteria make) and not from the original animals. This conclusion addressed none of the experiments and arguments set forth in the definitive 2016 refutation of the biofilm idea, published in the free online journal PLOS ONE.3 Stunningly, the eLife study authors cited six PLOS ONE papers, but not the most relevant one from 2016! Possibly the only way they could get away with their biofilm claim is to simply ignore all the evidence against it—the report’s third shortcoming.4

The team found no collagen in one dinosaur bone by using none of the techniques that specifically target collagen. Does this mean that no other fossils can have collagen? Not at all. Total reliance on lousy logic like hasty generalization, begging the question, and cherry picking clearly disqualifies the conclusions in this eLife report. In fact, if one must resort to scholarship this poor to defend the biofilm claim, then the microbial contamination story looks more ridiculous now than before this eLife report got published.

References
1. List of Biomaterial Fossil Papers (maintained). Online document, accessed June 20, 2019.
2. Saitta, E. T. et al. 2019. Cretaceous dinosaur bone contains recent organic material and provides an environment conducive to microbial communities. eLife. 8: e46205.
3. Schweitzer, M., H., A. E. Moyer, and W. Zheng. 2016. Testing the Hypothesis of Biofilm as a Source for Soft Tissue and Cell-Like Structures Preserved in Dinosaur Bone. PLOS ONE. 11(2): e0150238.
4. This represents a shameful case of cherry-picking, or the incomplete evidence fallacy.

Image: T. rex (Cretaceous dinosaur) in Osaka, Japan.

*Brian Thomas is a Research Associate at the Institute for Creation Research.
The Latest
NEWS
Did the Earth Tilt During the Flood?
Evolutionary scientists from the Chinese Academy of Sciences in Beijing and several universities in the United States, Italy, and Japan have recently claimed...

NEWS
ICR's New In-Depth Science Book: Chimps and Humans
Evolutionists frequently claim that human and chimp DNA are over 98% similar. They need this percentage to support their hypothesis that humans and...

NEWS
Fossil Chromatin Looks Young
What are the odds that a buried animal would still have intact DNA after 125 million years? Researchers publishing in the journal Communications Biology...

NEWS
Inside October 2021 Acts & Facts
How is the Lord’s handiwork on display at John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park? Does the universe look old? What can we learn about science and...

NEWS
Two-Volume Series: Restoring the Truth about Origins
The subject of origins continues to attract interest from the public and the scientific establishment. Understanding our origins informs us of who we are...

ACTS & FACTS
Creation Kids: Floods Form Fossils Fast
Christy Hardy and Susan Windsor* You’re never too young to be a creation scientist! Kids, discover fun facts about God’s creation with...

ACTS & FACTS
A Battle for Hearts
Since the ICR Discovery Center for Science & Earth History opened in fall of 2019, tens of thousands of people have walked through our doors. They...

APOLOGETICS
Eating Bugs Isn't Always So Simple
The Lord Jesus Christ deserves glory for why He made Earth’s diverse creatures, and He also deserves glory for the complicated details of how...

ACTS & FACTS
Does the Universe Look Old?
Since distant galaxies are billions of light-years away, some understandably assume that distant starlight must have taken billions of years to reach...

ACTS & FACTS
Hawaii Behind the Scenes
ICR Research Scientist Dr. Brian Thomas and ICR Video Producer Clint Loveness, with help from friends and family, recently shot footage in Maui, Hawaii,...