Yale University Prof: Darwin Was Wrong | The Institute for Creation Research

Yale University Prof: Darwin Was Wrong

A respected Yale University computer scientist has publicly expressed doubts about Darwinian evolution.1 In a column in the Claremont Review of Books, Dr. David Gelernter wrote that books by intelligent design (ID) proponents, especially Darwin’s Doubt by Stephen Meyer, convinced him that Darwinian evolution cannot be correct.2,3

More recently, Gelernter, along with Meyer and ID proponent Dr. David Berlinski, discussed the failure of Darwinism in an interview with Peter Robinson of the Hoover Institution.4

Although Gelernter has given up on Darwin, he hasn’t fully embraced intelligent design, in part because he sees the existence of evil as a major argument against such design.2,5 But this objection illustrates an important point: Intelligent design, by itself, is not a satisfactory explanation of our origins. Hard issues such as the existence of evil can’t be adequately answered simply by positing an unspecified designer. They require theological answers. This is why biblical creation is so important.

Berlinksi made another eye-opening comment: “[Intelligent design] doesn’t really…give us much. It’s not yet a theory….I’m much more persuaded by something that leads to a strong counterintuitive claim.”4

Berlinksi is correct that intelligent design “doesn’t…give us much.” It doesn’t explain why death, evil, and suffering exist, despite the undeniable design found in living things. Nor does it answer other big questions: Why do we humans have an innate sense of right and wrong? Why are billions of fossils found in water-deposited rocks all over the world? Why do cultures around the world have recollections of a global flood that nearly destroyed the human race?

The Bible gives us answers to these questions—answers rooted in real history. Moreover, they have led to “counterintuitive” but successful scientific predictions.6 Finally, the Bible also gives us the answer to the most important question of all: What does our Creator require of us in order to be at peace with him and gain eternal life?

[T]hat if you confess with your mouth the Lord Jesus and believe in your heart that God has raised Him from the dead, you will be saved. For with the heart one believes unto righteousness, and with the mouth confession is made unto salvation. For the Scripture says, “Whoever believes on Him will not be put to shame.” For there is no distinction between Jew and Greek, for the same Lord over all is rich to all who call upon Him. For “whoever calls on the name of the LORD shall be saved.” (Romans 10:9-13)

Perhaps Dr. David Gelernter’s conclusion will spark new discussion on God’s great design, and lead people to consult Genesis—and the whole of Scripture—for answers.

References
1. Kabbany-Fix, J. Famed Yale computer science professor quits believing Darwin’s theories. The College Fix. Posted July 30, 2019 at www.thecollegefix.com accessed on August 9, 2019.
2. Gelernter, D. Giving Up Darwin. Claremont Review of Books. 19 (2). Posted on claremont.org May 1, 2019, accessed on August 9, 2019.
3. Meyer, S. 2013. Darwin’s Doubt. San Francisco, CA: HarperOne.
4. Mathematical Challenges to Darwin’s Theory of Evolution with Berlinski, Meyer, and Gelernter. Posted on YouTube July 22, 2019.
5. Dr. Gelernter knows firsthand about the existence of evil in the world. He lost his right hand (and his right eye was injured) when he received a mail bomb from Ted Kaczynski, the so-called Unabomber, in 1993.
6. Humphreys, D. R. 2008. The Creation of Cosmic Magnetic Fields. Proceedings of the Sixth International Conference on Creationism. Pittsburgh, Dallas: Creation Science Fellowship and Institute for Creation Research, 213-230.

Stage image: Yale University

Dr. Hebert is Research Associate at the Institute for Creation Research and earned his Ph.D. in physics from the University of Texas at Dallas.
The Latest
NEWS
Subsurface Oceans on Two Uranian Moons?
A team of researchers led by University of North Dakota planetary scientist Dr. Caleb Strom concluded that the two Uranian moons Ariel and Miranda (directly...

NEWS
Slowing Plates Support High Flood Boundary
Flood geologists have predicted that plate motion slowed at the end of the Flood year, and now conventional scientists are finding it to be true. A...

NEWS
Microscopic Ingenuity: Stentor and the Case for Intelligent Design
What if the smallest creatures held the biggest clues to life’s design? A 2025 study in Nature Physics investigates the remarkable behaviors of...

CREATION PODCAST
Dr. Jeff Tomkins | A Scientist's Journey to Creationism | The...
ICR’s science staff have spent more than 50 years researching scientific evidence that refutes evolutionary philosophy...

NEWS
Early Fish Evolution?
The discovery of a new species of a plant or animal would probably not spark much excitement to the non-scientist. But in this case, the conditions...

NEWS
Make Plans to Attend Our Estate Planning Workshop at the Discovery...
Did you know that up to 75% of Americans over 18 have no retirement or estate plans? Don’t wait to prepare for the future. Join us on Saturday, October...

NEWS
Fossil Confusion in Ethiopia: Are Evolutionary Trees Built on...
A new study published in Nature describes the discovery of 13 fossilized teeth from the Ledi-Geraru site in Ethiopia. They have been dated to between...

NEWS
The Only Mesozoic Dragonfly in Canada—Is a Dragonfly
In 2023, an undergraduate student from McGill University discovered a new dragonfly species in Alberta, Canada. In fact, “This is the first ever...

CREATION PODCAST
Dr. Jake Hebert | Journey to ICR | The Creation Podcast: Episode...
ICR’s science staff have spent more than 50 years researching scientific evidence that refutes evolutionary philosophy...

NEWS
Oldest Evidence of Butterflies
Insects such as the ubiquitous butterfly belong to the huge phylum Arthropoda (creatures having paired, jointed appendages and a chitinous exoskeleton)....