Something Fishy about Global Warming Claims

After the Flood, God promised Noah that Earth would have predictable patterns of climates and seasons: “While the earth remains, seedtime and harvest, cold and heat, winter and summer, and day and night shall not cease.”1 This promise is trustworthy because God is trustworthy, and He controls Earth’s climates and seasons.

This promise is trustworthy because God is trustworthy, and He controls Earth’s climates and seasons. Tweet: This promise is trustworthy because God is trustworthy, and He controls Earth’s climates and seasons.

Something Fishy about Global Warming Claims: http://www.icr.org/article/10460/

@icrscience

But recently God’s promise has been distrusted, doubted, and denied by many who assert that human activities are so out of control we should fear the loss of previously stable climate patterns. In effect, these alarmists ignore God’s promise and His sovereign control, as if humans can determine the destiny of Earth’s climate.

But what if government reports support notions of man-made global warming and an upcoming climate crisis? Would that prove God has lost His stabilizing grip on Earth’s environmental parameters? Consider the Alaska pollock, the cod-like whitefish some say is now the number one money finfish in America’s food industry. Huge pollock populations once filled certain areas of the Bering Sea and North Pacific, but the southern edge of their range is shrinking. Some suggest the pollocks are migrating north due to climate change.2 Is this the case?

Marine biologists and biogeography ecologists study regional changes in oceanic fish populations.2,3

We expect fish stocks to naturally fluctuate with changes in climate [such as when Baltic herring relocated about A.D. 1300 as the Medieval Warm Period transitioned into the Little Ice Age]. Usually, during periods of warming or cooling, fish stocks residing at the polar ends of the population’s range increase or decrease accordingly, while the reverse happens at the other end.2

If huge populations of Alaska pollock relocate north or south, that migration’s cause is a big deal—not just for the food industry but also because global warming advocacy is a billion-dollar industry. Government-funded research projects often depend upon climate change theories.2

Pollock are sorted on board the NOAA ship Miller Freeman during a 2007 assessment.
Image credit: Copyright © 2007. I. Spies. Alaska Fisheries Science Center. Used in accordance with federal copyright (fair use doctrine) law. Usage by ICR does not imply endorsement of copyright holder.

However, government databases are not immune to error. Scientific analyses cannot have stronger validity than their underlying data. Misinformation can multiply when filtered through multiple users. Database errors accrue and snowball, infecting and proliferating into multi-generational “viral” outcomes, due in part to “veneer review” and statistics-distorting cherry-picking.2-4 When billions of dollars hang in the balance, both scientific research (i.e., observing and collecting data) and scientific analysis (i.e., sorting and interpreting data) are vulnerable to compromise and corruption.2,4

Government databases on the fishing industry rely on at-sea reporting that includes inspector monitoring of fishing quotas.2 However, the information the inspectors collect can be unreliable.

We discovered that our estimates [of the total catch tonnage] were about double the catches reported to us. All signs pointed to tampering of the scales.…The catcher boats now delivered [at different places] and at all hours. Previously they had delivered to one main site on the [mothership] deck and only during daylight hours.5

Dishonest commercial fishermen habitually underreport catches, deceptively circumventing inspector audits. Commercial fishing motherships often obstruct or evade monitors, sometimes reporting only half the catches received.1,3 Consequently, government databases misreport the real situation.

Should further research, farther north, be looked at to see if climate change is really causing the pollock population to migrate northward? Could it be the cause-and-effect reality is embarrassingly simple and overlooked6 as evolutionists rush to blame global warming for yet another ecosystem alteration?

In the case of pollock, several stocks at either end of their range in the north Pacific Ocean have decreased recently, leading to suspicion of overfishing as the primary cause for the population decreases.2

Despite what popular science purports to show, we can rely on God’s Word. Tweet: Despite what popular science purports to show, we can rely on God’s Word.

Something Fishy about Global Warming Claims: http://www.icr.org/article/10460/

@icrscience

This is but one example of how careful fact-finding refutes global warming alarmism, corroborating God’s promise in Genesis 8:22. Despite what popular science purports to show, we can rely on God’s Word.

References

  1. Genesis 8:22. Notice that God made this climatology-relevant promise to both humanity and the animals who survived the Flood.
  2. Bailey, K. M. 2013. Billion-Dollar Fish: The Untold Story of Alaska Pollock. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2-44, 46-88, 199-215; quotation from page 16.
  3. Miles, E. et al. 1982. The Management of Marine Regions: The North Pacific. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 160-165, 172, 184-193, 220-223; Kasahara, H. 1972. Japanese Distant-Water Fisheries: A Review. Fishery Bulletin. 70 (2): 227-282.
  4. Guliuzza, R. J. 2009. Consensus Science: The Rise of a Scientific Elite. Acts & Facts. 38 (5): 4; Johnson, J. J. S. 2015. Forensic Science Frustrated by “Peer Review.” Acts & Facts. 44 (2): 18; Johnson, J. J. S. 2015. Cherry Picking Data Is the Pits. Acts & Facts. 44 (7): 19. See also Proverbs 20:10, 23; Micah 6:11.
  5. Bailey, Billion-Dollar Fish, 4.
  6. Johnson, J. J. S. 2014. Pine Needles, Limes, and Other Simple Solutions. Creation Research Society Quarterly. 50 (3): 193-194.

* Dr. Johnson is Associate Professor of Apologetics and Chief Academic Officer at the Institute for Creation Research.

The Latest
NEWS
Amazing Design of Black Widow Web Silk
Evidence for creation is seen in both the sudden origin1 of spiders, as demonstrated in the fossil record, and their amazing design.2 All spiders are...

NEWS
Reptile Footprints Advance Flood Explanation
Salamander-like footprints preserved in sandstone have long fascinated Grand Canyon hikers and rafters. Insights from a new study of the track patterns...

DAYS OF PRAISE DEVOTIONALS
Winter 2018
...

ACTS & FACTS
God's Greatest Gift
We can never fully comprehend what it meant for the transcendent and infinite Creator God to become finite man. Yet Jesus, who was “so much better...

APOLOGETICS
Can and Will Be Used Against You
Is it fair to refute evolutionists’ claims with their own words?1,2 “For by your words you will be justified, and by your words you...