Beardogs: Bears, Dogs, or Something Else? | The Institute for Creation Research
Beardogs: Bears, Dogs, or Something Else?

My wife recently read an article titled “Bear Dogs of El Paso” in a Texas magazine. The second sentence stated that “these ancient mammals” were “ancestral to both bears and dogs.”1 She wanted to know if fossils really show this, so I started digging.

The article cited paleontologist Susumu Tomiya and anatomist Jack Tseng. A search for their names found a 2016 technical report on beardogs written by them in the journal Royal Society Open Science.2 The pair re-analyzed two fossils previously labeled as generic carnivores by other scientists. New CT scans showed skull features that suggested both fossils belonged to the specific category of carnivores called beardogs. Does the name mean beardogs evolved into dogs or bears? Not at all. Here’s what I found.

Beardog fossils and dog fossils are found in the same rock layers, which means they lived at the same time. Tweet: Beardog fossils and dog fossils are found in the same rock layers, which means they lived at the same time.

Beardogs: Bears, Dogs, or Something Else? http://www.icr.org/article/beardogs-bears-dogs-or-something-else

@icrscience @icrbthomas

#Science #Fossil

First, near the end of the “Bear Dogs” article, the author quotes Tseng as saying, “Bear dogs and true dogs shared a common ancestor…but there is little evidence that true dogs are direct descendants of bear dogs.”1 Wait, what? If there is little evidence that dogs evolved from beardogs, then why did the author write earlier in the article that beardogs were dogs’ ancestors? These statements clearly clashed, so I needed to learn more.

In 2016, the journal Science stated:

Bear dogs, scientifically known as amphicyonids, get their common name from their general resemblance to modern-day bears and dogs, especially in their body shape and posture, but they are, in fact, only distantly related to these lineages.3

So, like Tseng, this evolutionary author admits that beardogs are only distant relatives—not ancestors—of dogs.

A University at Buffalo summary of the 2016 Royal Society report said that beardogs have a characteristic bone-enclosed space in their skulls near the ears.4 Tseng and Tomiya found these spaces in their tiny, Chihuahua-size Texas fossils. An earlier 2001 study compared small beardog skulls to actual dog skulls. It said, “From their earliest appearance, canids [dogs] fully enclose the auditory region.”5 But if dogs evolved, shouldn’t early ancestors have less dog-like characteristics? Instead, dogs have remained dogs, just as amphicyonids stayed true to their own form.

The 2001 report also noted that the same rock layers that have amphicyonids have even more dog fossils in them. How could one evolve into the other if they lived at the same time and place?

The Royal Society report said, “While amphicyonid systematics has a long history of study, the origin and initial evolution of the group during the Eocene have long remained nebulous.”2 And the new assignment of the two fossils as amphicyonids left their evolutionary origins just as cloudy as before. Even after this designation, “It’s not clear where or when amphicyonids evolved,” according to Science.3

I needed no fossil expertise to determine that beardogs show no real evolution. All I had to do was read the secular scientists’ own conclusions. I told my wife that despite what her article said, four different evolutionists admitted that beardogs probably did not evolve into modern dogs. Now she’s writing a letter to the editor about the article’s inaccuracy.

Beardogs were not dogs, bears, or ancestors of either. Fossils agree they were their own created kind. Tweet: Beardogs were not dogs, bears, or ancestors of either. Fossils agree they were their own created kind.

Beardogs: Bears, Dogs, or Something Else? http://www.icr.org/article/beardogs-bears-dogs-or-something-else

@icrscience @icrbthomas

#Science #Fossil

Beardogs were not dogs, bears, or ancestors of either. Fossils agree they were their own created kind.

References

  1. Deeringer, M. Bear Dogs of El Paso. Texas Co-op Power, June 29, 2018.
  2. Tomiya, S. and Z. J. Tseng. 2016. Whence the beardogs? Reappraisal of the Middle to Late Eocene ‘Miacis’ from Texas, USA, and the origin of Amphicyonidae (Mammalia, Carnivora). Royal Society Open Science. 3: 160518.
  3. Perkins, S. ‘Bear dogs’ once lived in southern Texas. Science News. Posted on sciencemag.org October 11, 2016, accessed June 1, 2018.
  4. Goldbaum, E. From unknown to beardog: Findings rescue fossils from “trashbin” genus. University at Buffalo News Center. Posted on buffalo.edu October 12, 2016, accessed June 1, 2018.
  5. Hunt, R. M., Jr. 2001. Small Oligocene Amphicyonids from North America (Paradaphoenus, Mammalia, Carnivora). American Museum Novitates. 3331: 18.

* Mr. Thomas is Science Writer at the Institute for Creation Research and earned his M.S. in biotechnology from Stephen F. Austin State University.

Image credit: Copyright © T. Batar. Used in accordance with federal copyright (fair use doctrine) law. Usage by ICR does not imply endorsement of copyright holder.

Cite this article: Brian Thomas, Ph.D. 2018. Beardogs: Bears, Dogs, or Something Else?. Acts & Facts. 47 (8).

The Latest
COVID-19
Some Fake Coronavirus News Used to Spread Malware
As a systems administrator, I see thousands of emails come in where someone is trying to get a user to click on a link. A lot of these are just plain old...

NEWS
Traces of "Oldest Ancestor" Found
A new study released on March 23, 2020, claims that evolutionary scientists have identified the oldest human ancestor. The fossil evidence for this assertion...

COVID-19
Three Positives from COVID-19
Coronavirus (COVID-19) is no surprise to God. God knew about this pandemic before the dawn of His creation. Some people may question why God allows such...

COVID-19
The Gospel and COVID-19
It is obvious that life in America, and most parts of the world, has drastically changed in the last few months due to the novel coronavirus. Whether we...

COVID-19
A Time for Firsts Amid COVID-19
All of us have experience with firsts, and today is no exception as America sails through the uncharted waters of the coronavirus pandemic (COVID-19)....

COVID-19
What’s the Difference Between Virus and Bacteria?
As we are embroiled in a worldwide COVID-19 pandemic, it is important to know the basics of these tragic viral infections and why the medical community...

NEWS
ICR Beginning Search for a New President
As was noted in my article “Biblical Succession” in the April issue of Acts & Facts, the ICR Board of Trustees has authorized a national...

COVID-19
Potential Coronavirus Treatments Enter Large Clinical Trials
Some good news in potential treatment options for COVID-19 was reported in the American journal Science.1 Four new treatment options were being...

NEWS
Yellowstone Supervolcano Unlikely to Blow
For several years, secular scientists have been predicting a possible supervolcano eruption at Yellowstone National Park. Recently, the London Daily Mail...

NEWS
Deep Water Squid Communication Mystifies Scientists
In the deep, dark, cold waters of the Pacific Ocean—about 1,500 feet below the surface— hundreds of Humboldt squid the size of small humans...