Another Feathered Dinosaur Tale | The Institute for Creation Research

Another Feathered Dinosaur Tale

On December 8, 2016, a science news story broke that researchers had found entombed in mid-Cretaceous amber a dinosaur tail complete with "primitive plumage"—i.e., feathers.1

This is exciting for evolutionists because evolutionary theory posits that birds have an ancient theropod ancestor. Through time and chance, the front legs of that small, heavy-tailed, bipedal dinosaur supposedly "turned into" efficient, aerodynamic wings, and the creature somehow sprouted flight feathers in all their complexity. Unfortunately, the scientific case for reptilian scales "turning into" feathers has yet to be made.

National Geographic characteristically and enthusiastically crowed of this recent discovery: "To scientists’ delight, the incredible appendage from 99 million years ago is covered in feathers."2 Such celebration is premature, however, as the following observations show.

What was the original source of this small, incomplete sample? It was bought from a market trader, which is always a scientific risk, especially since it involves fantastic transitional claims. This fragmentary evidence was purchased in China, another red flag. Consider the tale of the hoax species Archaeoraptor of National Geographic fame. That Chinese "dino-bird" fossil turned out to be pieced together from multiple fossils and tile grout.3

Are there other possibilities and/or explanations for this "dinosaur tail" other than that it is definitely a "feathered dinosaur"? Good scientific research explores other avenues, starting with the question "Can I be certain that this fragment really belongs to a dinosaur?" Will the public hear from evolutionists who are not convinced of the dinosaur-bird transitional nature of this questionable find? The interested public is urged to read the Current Biology article to better appreciate the use of cautious words and phrases by the authors regarding the significance of this discovery: "evolutionary patterns remain difficult to interpret," "taxonomic placement is uncertain," "suggests," etc.

The Current Biology article cites "the spatial arrangement of follicles and feathers on the body, and micrometer-scale features of the plumage. Many feathers exhibit a short, slender rachis with alternating barbs and a uniform series of contiguous barbules."1 The authors note three times that the feathers they observed resemble modern bird feathers. Why didn’t the authors explain the very close resemblance of these feathers to those of birds living today? Indeed, the first time feathers are found in the fossil record, they are 100% feathers with no transitional features.

And there are further considerations beyond the presence of feathers. In order for birds to maintain feather structure and uniformity, they are designed with a bill that is critical for preening to clean, align, and cover their feathers with an oily, water-repellant substance. Did this "non-avialan [sic] theropod" (coelurosaur) have a beak designed for preening?

The article also reported a fascinating discovery of "carbonized soft tissues [that] offer a glimpse of preservational potential and history for the inclusion; abundant Fe2+ suggests that vestiges of primary hemoglobin and ferritin remain trapped within the tail."1 With such amazing organic material preserved for all these supposed "99 million years," has there been an effort to recover and sequence DNA from the tail material? What about carbon-14 analysis, which is valid for only thousands of years? What would such empirical research do to the "99 million years" stated by evolutionists?

The authors found only two delineated vertebrae in the amber sample, correctly ascertaining that the original owner probably had more. However, they state that this animal had a "total caudal vertebral count not reasonably less than 15, and likely greater than 25," and then use their assumed "25 or greater vertebrae" as an argument that it was not a bird. Yet, extinct bird species like Archaeopteryx had long, bony tails, as did Jeholornis. The authors tried to exclude these birds from consideration by claiming the larger number of caudal vertebrae, but admitted that even the avian species Jeholornis did have more than 25 caudal vertebrae. They further concluded in the Supplemental Information that the presence of a central groove on the caudal centra of the specimen excluded it from the avialan taxa, but added that "the possibility of its presence in the two known long-tailed birds Archaeopteryx and Jeholornis cannot be excluded."

In short, all the available evidence about this "feathered dinosaur" tail in amber suggests it was actually a bird.

References

  1. Xing, L. et al. 2016. A Feathered Dinosaur Tail with Primitive Plumage Trapped in Mid-Cretaceous Amber. Current Biology. 26: 1-9. 
  2. Romey, K. First Dinosaur Tail Found Preserved in Amber. National Geographic. Posted on nationalgeographic.com December 8, 2016, accessed December 9, 2016. 
  3. Austin, S. A. 2000. Archaeoraptor: Feathered Dinosaur from National Geographic Doesn't Fly. Acts & Facts. 29 (3). 

Image credit: Copyright © 2016 Elsevier Ltd. Adapted for use in accordance with federal copyright (fair use doctrine) law. Usage by ICR does not imply endorsement of copyright holder.

* Mr. Sherwin is Research Associate, Senior Lecturer, and Science Writer at the Institute for Creation Research.

Article posted on December 10, 2016.

The Latest
CREATION PODCAST
Water vs. Wind: The Controversial Coconino | The Creation Podcast:...
Welcome to the sixth episode in a series called “The Failures of Old Earth Creationism.” Many Christians attempt to fit old...

NEWS
Fossil Fish Finally Filmed
The bizarre lobe-finned coelacanth (Latimeria chalumnae) “that flourished some 350 million years ago”1 continues to be a thorn...

NEWS
The Mosasaur: A Giant Sea Dragon
Mosasaurs (order Squamata) were massive marine lizards that were common in the pre-Flood oceans. Therefore, it is not surprising that their fossils...

DAYS OF PRAISE DEVOTIONALS
Summer 2025
...

NEWS
Was Life Detected on a Distant Planet?
There was celebration, albeit briefly, for the discovery of potential life on a planet called K2-18b, which is 124 lightyears away from Earth. The...

NEWS
Ichthyosaur Graveyard Explained by the Flood
Ichthyosaurs are marine reptiles that occur globally in the same rock layers as dinosaurs. Specimens with babies support the idea that they gave live...

CREATION PODCAST
What Do We Do With Geology's Unconforming Features? | The Creation...
Welcome to the fifth episode in a series called “The Failures of Old Earth Creationism.” Many Christians attempt to fit old...

NEWS
Freshwater Fish Fossil in Australia
Yet another fish fossil has been discovered. This one was found in the Australian desert and was dated by evolutionists to be “15 million years...

NEWS
May 2025 ICR Wallpaper
"Now may the God of hope fill you with all joy and peace in believing, that you may abound in hope by the power of the Holy Spirit." (Romans...

NEWS
Acoustic Communication in Animals
We are all familiar with vocalizations in the animal world. For example, dogs bark, birds sing, frogs croak, and whales send forth their own distinct...