The Prestige of Historical Geology | The Institute for Creation Research
The Prestige of Historical Geology

As an incoming university student of geology I was required to take a class in Historical Geology. I can recall my professor saying, "back in the Dark Ages . . ." intelligent people actually believed the Bible, including doctrines like a few-thousand-year-old earth, a world-covering flood, and a built-in fixity to the created kinds of plants and animals. He spoke with great authority that earth's age had been measured at 4.6 billion years, the fossil record was not one of judgment but a testimony of unlimited biologic change, and that design and purpose were unscientific terms. Where did he get such authority?

Nearly ten years later I came as a trembling sinner to Christ for forgiveness and salvation. All my science was powerless to challenge the historical claims that Christ's gracious work on the cross was sufficient for my sins, that a loving God had actually created the earth in real space and time in such a way that I was accountable to Him, and that, because of history I was a fallen creature in need of a Redeemer. When I tested historical claims, I tested them against outside historic sources, and checked for internal contradiction; empirical testing was out of the question. But neither could the claims of historical geology be tested empirically! How had historical geology ever attained the status of "science"?

Before the mid-seventeenth century, the earth was viewed as eternal, and endlessly cyclical; there was little concept of a history to the earth. With the Reformation, however, the earth was seen as having a beginning and an end, and so a linear view of history emerged. Men like Steno, Hooke, and Ray began to make sense of fossils and rocks in terms of creation, Flood, and post-Flood periods, and for about 150 years was the dominant view.

With the Enlightenment, however, the ideas of men like Descartes, Hutton, and Buffon, took hold. By extrapolating present-day processes into the past, they reasoned, a purely "scientific" earth history could emerge, one which offered the hope of calibrating earth history in terms of real years. Their goal was to achieve, for the study of earth history, the kind of prestige enjoyed by the mathematical sciences like mechanics, optics, and astronomy. In those disciplines, the experimenter assumed there were no super-natural happenings inside his lab. No hobgoblins, for example, smuggled away his reagents while he was not looking. The Enlightenment thinkers simply borrowed this assumption, legitimate to empirical science, and extrapolated it into all eternity past -- to arrive at a "scientific" view of earth history. This slight of hand, in borrowing an assumption legitimate to one endeavor, and applying it to another, is the basis for the prestige of historical geology and of our countless museums of natural history.

A banner should be hung over the entrance to our museums of natural history that reads: Welcome. We assume no supernatural entity ever had a hand in earth's past. We apologize if you find our claims questionable, that life arose without the help of intelligence, and that geologic history consists of a long succession of "prehistoric ages." These are merely the best stories we can come up with, given our naturalistic starting position. Enter here if you want the "scientific" view of earth history. For truth, you will need to go back to Genesis.

*William A. Hoesch, M.S. geology, is Research Assistant in Geology.

Cite this article: Hoesch, W. 2007. The Prestige of Historical Geology. Acts & Facts. 36 (4).

The Latest
COVID-19
Teaching Kids About Creation During Quarantine
Thanks to public health recommendations regarding COVID-19, many families are spending more time together than ever before. If that’s your situation,...

COVID-19
Some Fake Coronavirus News Used to Spread Malware
As a systems administrator, I see thousands of emails come in where someone is trying to get a user to click on a link. A lot of these are just plain old...

NEWS
Turtles, Birdwatching, and Living Through Tough Times
How can learning about turtles and doing some birdwatching be useful during this time? Local disasters are declared, and ordinary life activities are restricted,...

NEWS
Volcanic Ash Turns to Stone in Months
How long does it take for the volcanic ash to turn to stone? Most uniformitarian scientists claim this is a slow process that should take many years, even...

NEWS
Traces of "Oldest Ancestor" Found
A new study released on March 23, 2020, claims that evolutionary scientists have identified the oldest human ancestor. The fossil evidence for this assertion...

COVID-19
Three Positives from COVID-19
Coronavirus (COVID-19) is no surprise to God. God knew about this pandemic before the dawn of His creation. Some people may question why God allows such...

COVID-19
The Gospel and COVID-19
It is obvious that life in America, and most parts of the world, has drastically changed in the last few months due to the novel coronavirus. Whether we...

COVID-19
A Time for Firsts Amid COVID-19
All of us have experience with firsts, and today is no exception as America sails through the uncharted waters of the coronavirus pandemic (COVID-19)....

COVID-19
What’s the Difference Between Virus and Bacteria?
As we are embroiled in a worldwide COVID-19 pandemic, it is important to know the basics of these tragic viral infections and why the medical community...

NEWS
ICR Beginning Search for a New President
As was noted in my article “Biblical Succession” in the April issue of Acts & Facts, the ICR Board of Trustees has authorized a national...