Mayflower Pilgrims, Simian DNA, and Straw Men | The Institute for Creation Research

Mayflower Pilgrims, Simian DNA, and Straw Men

Both the Mayflower Pilgrims and biblical creationists are unjustly targeted for straw man vilifications using misleading, false accusations. A straw man fallacy occurs when a critic disagrees with someone based on an alleged fault or flaw—yet the opponent is not guilty of that alleged fault or flaw.1 Consider the difference: fighting and defeating a healthy human opponent versus beating up a lifeless scarecrow-like effigy of one’s opponent (a straw man). Anyone can defeat a lifeless scarecrow.

However, defeating a living foe requires a true contest. Yet, critics often claim “fake fight” victories when they dishonestly defeat historical heroes they dislike. Fake-fight victories are also claimed—on false pretenses—over Scripture by evolutionists who crow about disproving a scientific “claim” that biblical creationists never made in the first place.

We’ll first look at how straw man mischaracterizations are dishonestly cast via sloppy history. Then we’ll see how similar misreporting is used to mischaracterize real facts via sloppy science.

Sloppy History

Some accuse the Mayflower Pilgrims, who arrived at Plymouth exactly 400 years ago, of stealing the land of Native Americans. But this misrepresentation of the Pilgrims’ history is inexcusably misreported. Actually, the Pilgrims settled on land that was intentionally abandoned by the nearby native tribes because that land was deemed cursed and haunted. Previous tribes who had lived there died of an unusual plague about three years before the Pilgrims arrived.2

Plymouth Plantation was thus settled on land rejected by local tribes. To accuse the Pilgrims of “stealing” Native American land is an irresponsible failure to inspect actual historical truth. Accordingly, whoever denigrates the Pilgrims’ settlement as somehow unethical is really condemning the faults of a straw man who never lived at Plymouth.

Sloppy Science

Some evolutionists assert that there is almost no difference between human DNA and simian (monkey/ape-like) DNA, insinuating that the Genesis creation account cannot be scientifically trusted. Suppose an evolutionist argues that genetics evidence clashes with the Genesis record, saying, “When compared to the chimpanzee, the two species [human and chimp] differ by as little as 1 to 2%”—that would be a straw man fallacy. Why? Because the actual difference between the human and chimpanzee genomes is at least 15%, so trying to “match” a 1 to 2% genomic difference with the biblical account will never line up.3

Instead, Genesis-affirming scientists expect less—though still some—genomic overlap between chimpanzees and humans because God designed humans and simians to inhabit the same world, breathe the same air, eat many of the same foods, drink the same water, etc. But to imply that Genesis must “force fit” a genomic difference range of only 1 to 2% is to flippantly advocate a straw man argument when the real genomic difference is beyond 15%.3

Don’t be fooled by the straw man logical fallacy of those who disparage the Pilgrims as you thank God for blessing America through their bravery 400 years ago. Likewise, don’t be fooled by evolutionists who imply that human genotypes almost identically resemble chimpanzee genotypes—because Darwinists who promote such sloppy science are just unjustly monkeying with the facts.4

References

  1. McDurmon, J. 2011. Biblical Logic in Theory and Practice: Refuting the Fallacies of Humanism, Darwinism, Atheism, and Just Plain Stupidity. Powder Springs, GA: The American Vision, Inc., 203-213.
  2. Bradford, W. 1989. Of Plymouth Plantation, 1620–1647. New York: Alfred A Knopf, 87.
  3. Tomkins, J. P. 2018. Separate Studies Converge on Human-Chimp DNA Dissimilarity. Acts & Facts. 47 (11): 9. See also Tomkins, J. P. 2016. Analysis of 101 Chimpanzee Trace Read Data Sets: Assessment of Their Overall Similarity to Human and Possible Contamination with Human DNA. Answers Research Journal. 9: 294-298.
  4. 1 Timothy 6:20-21.

* Dr. Johnson is Associate Professor of Apologetics and Chief Academic Officer at the Institute for Creation Research.

Cite this article: James J. S. Johnson, J.D., Th.D. 2020. Mayflower Pilgrims, Simian DNA, and Straw Men. Acts & Facts. 49 (11).

The Latest
NEWS
The Origin of Eukaryotes
Eukaryotes are multicellular organisms that contain diverse differentiated cell types. Within almost every cell there are subcellular compartments called...

CREATION PODCAST
Water vs. Wind: The Controversial Coconino | The Creation Podcast:...
Welcome to the sixth episode in a series called “The Failures of Old Earth Creationism.” Many Christians attempt to fit old...

NEWS
Fossil Fish Finally Filmed
The bizarre lobe-finned coelacanth (Latimeria chalumnae) “that flourished some 350 million years ago”1 continues to be a thorn...

NEWS
The Mosasaur: A Giant Sea Dragon
Mosasaurs (order Squamata) were massive marine lizards that were common in the pre-Flood oceans. Therefore, it is not surprising that their fossils...

DAYS OF PRAISE DEVOTIONALS
Summer 2025
...

NEWS
Was Life Detected on a Distant Planet?
There was celebration, albeit briefly, for the discovery of potential life on a planet called K2-18b, which is 124 lightyears away from Earth. The...

NEWS
Ichthyosaur Graveyard Explained by the Flood
Ichthyosaurs are marine reptiles that occur globally in the same rock layers as dinosaurs. Specimens with babies support the idea that they gave live...

CREATION PODCAST
What Do We Do With Geology's Unconforming Features? | The Creation...
Welcome to the fifth episode in a series called “The Failures of Old Earth Creationism.” Many Christians attempt to fit old...

NEWS
Freshwater Fish Fossil in Australia
Yet another fish fossil has been discovered. This one was found in the Australian desert and was dated by evolutionists to be “15 million years...

NEWS
May 2025 ICR Wallpaper
"Now may the God of hope fill you with all joy and peace in believing, that you may abound in hope by the power of the Holy Spirit." (Romans...