Testing the Cavefish Model: An Organism-focused Theory of Testing the Cavefish Model: An Organism-focused Theory of Biological Design Biological Design | The Institute for Creation Research

 
Testing the Cavefish Model: An Organism-focused Theory of Testing the Cavefish Model: An Organism-focused Theory of Biological Design Biological Design

by Michael J. Boyle, Ph.D., Brian Thomas, Ph.D., Jeffrey P. Tomkins, Ph.D., and Randy J. Guliuzza, P.E., M.D.

In Proceedings of the International Conference on Creationism. 9: 120-143, article 17.

Abstract

The Institute for Creation Research (ICR) is performing controlled experiments to test the response of an organism to different environmental conditions. The animal model is Astyanax mexicanus (Mexican tetra), a freshwater fish with two well-differentiated, interfertile morphotypes: eyed surface-dwelling fish (surface fish) with a distinct pigmentation pattern, and eyeless cave-dwelling fish (cavefish) with minimal pigmentation. For this research, we have established and equipped a new biology laboratory to investigate the mechanisms and process of adaptation in this model. Preliminary results from experiments with mature adult A. mexicanus include the following: (1) Cavefish increase pigmentation across their body when exposed to high-intensity light; (2) Cavefish exhibit behavioral and physiological acclimation to high CO2 (low pH) water; (3) Surface fish decrease pigmentation across their body and labor during respiration in high CO2 (low pH) water; (4) Adult cavefish and surface fish respond to experimental treatments within weeks of treatment; and (5) Responses to treatments by both morphotypes are not limited to multigenerational genetic inheritance. The first result implies that UV light may stimulate melanosome production in adult cavefish through biochemical induction of a latent melanin synthesis pathway. Second, pre-acclimation by cavefish to acidic water chemistry likely reflects conditions within their native cave environments. Third, the comparative loss of pigmentation and associated respiratory challenges in adult surface fish exposed to darkness and high CO2 (low pH) suggest they actively self-adjust. And in contrast to cavefish, non-acclimated surface fish indicate they are outside of their native environment. The significance of this research is multifaceted. At the 8th ICC, Guliuzza and Gaskill (2018) introduced a novel paradigm: Continuous Environmental Tracking (CET). This model infers that organisms actively and continuously track conditions within specific environments to self-adjust through internal mechanisms that integrate molecular, biochemical, cellular, physiological and behavioral functionality of the whole organism. These mechanisms are predicted to operate by the same integrative principles that govern human-engineered control systems, suggesting that fish and other animals make highly-regulated responses in order to compensate for changes in external conditions that may exceed their routine efforts to maintain homeostasis. Moreover, the model also predicts that organisms can modify the course of their development; that adaptive larval and adult traits are sometimes reversible; that epigenetic modifications are heritable across multiple generations; and that common phenotypic traits will be observed among a diversity of organisms living in similar environments. Our predictions are testable.

Click here to read the full article text.

The Latest
NEWS
Quietly ''Devolving'' Tomatoes?
Apparently, evolution (and natural selection) can do almost anything: If new forms appear, the credit goes to creative natural selection; if old...

CREATION PODCAST
Five Unforgettable Lessons Learned from the Scopes Trial | The...
The Scopes Trial is one of the most famous court cases in American history, and this year marks its one hundredth anniversary....

NEWS
Yet Another Revised Age for the Land-Animal Ancestor
An allegedly vital piece of animal evolution was first discovered in 1984 in Scotland. Conventional scientists suggested the fossil of Westlothiana...

NEWS
Dr. James S. Johnson Goes Home to the Lord
Dr. James S. Johnson, chief academic officer and associate professor of apologetics for ICR’s School of Biblical Apologetics (SOBA), joined his...

NEWS
Pluto’s Largest Moon Looks Young
When the New Horizons space probe captured images of Pluto and its large moon Charon as it flew by in 2015, conventional scientists were surprised by...

NEWS
55-Million-Year-Old Tree Frog…Is Still a Tree Frog
In the 1990s, Australian paleontologists discovered fossil frog bones during a dig in Murgon, Queensland.1 This new species of frog—Litoria...

NEWS
Pastor and Longtime ICR Supporter Dr. John MacArthur Now with...
Faithful ICR supporter and pastor Dr. John MacArthur went home to be with the Lord on Monday, July 14, 2025, completing his 86-year pilgrimage.1...

CREATION PODCAST
Setting Sights on Scopes: The Truth Behind the Infamous Monkey...
The Scopes Trial is one of the most famous court cases in American history, and this year marks its one hundredth anniversary. Often,...

NEWS
Did Earthworms Rewrite Their DNA to Survive on Land?
An earthworm news story was recently posted that openly questions Darwin’s gradual and slow evolutionary progress in the living world.1...

NEWS
Mysterious Erosion Confirms High Flood Boundary
Two separate research reports arrived at a similar conclusion.1,2 Both found an episode of mysterious erosion had occurred near the end of...