Extinct Radionuclides | The Institute for Creation Research
Extinct Radionuclides

What do you think of when you hear the word extinct? Dinosaurs, perhaps? Maybe saber-toothed cats, mammoths, or short-faced bears? We might also include the more recent Bali tiger, passenger pigeon, and West African black rhinoceros.

There are a group of radioisotopes that are typically termed “extinct” (Table 1). They are defined as radionuclides that formed by stellar nucleosynthesis before the formation of the solar system about 4.6 billion years ago.1 These radionuclides were somehow injected into the molecular cloud from which our solar system supposedly originated. They were thought to have decayed to an unmeasurable presence in solar system objects. It has long been believed that their daughter isotopes can be used to gain information about the early stages of the solar system’s formation. Specifically, the short decay time for 26Al (aluminum) has been used to measure the time between its supposed injection into the molecular cloud and the cloud’s subsequent collapse.

Table 1. Radionuclides thought to be absent from Earth and solar system objects due to their relatively short half-lives (Ma = millions of years)
 

There are at least four significant problems with this hypothetical scenario. First, it assumes the classical deep time model for the solar system’s origin. Second, it has been shown that the formation of elements with atomic numbers above iron in the periodic table in a supernova is unlikely.2 Third, it doesn’t present a viable mechanism for how the extinct radionuclides were transported from a nearby supernova to the supposed molecular cloud that generated our solar system. Fourth, the so-called extinct radionuclides still display measurable abundance ratios for Earth rocks (Table 1).

26Al was also found in meteoritic material in 1977.3,4 The most likely nuclear reactions for generating 26Al from 27Al are 27Al (p,d) 26Al and 27Al (n,2n) 26Al.5 Cross-sections for each reaction are not particularly large: 26 mb for the first and 116 mb for the second.6 In addition, both reactions exhibit very sharp production cross-section peaks, the first at ~27 MeV and the second at ~20 MeV. While the production cross-sections for 26Al make its production in meteoritic material containing 27Al possible under the right conditions, it’s not probable. So, its presence in meteoritic material presents a problem for secular science’s dating of the solar system.

From Table 1, it’s clear that the so-called extinct radionuclides exist in Earth’s lithosphere at measurable levels. This means that either they must be continually produced in the near surface rocks, as is hypothesized for 26Al in meteorites, or Earth is much younger than secular science demands. The existence of measurable amounts of 60Fe, 53Mn, 26Al, 36Cl, or 41Ca in Cambrian and Precambrian rock layers makes the argument of continuous production problematic for secular science and supports a recent creation by imposing an upper limit of ~1.5 x 107 years on the age of the earth.7

References

  1. Extinct radionuclide. Wikipedia. Posted on en.wikipedia.org.
  2. Cupps, V. R. 2018. Stellar Nucleosynthesis: Where Did Heavy Elements Come From? Acts & Facts. 47 (1): 10-12.
  3. Lee, T., D. A. Papanastassiou, and G. J. Wasserburg. 1977. Aluminum-26 in the Early Solar System: Fossil or Fuel? The Astrophysical Journal. 211: L107-L110.
  4. Clayton, D. D. 1994. Production of 26Al and other extinct radionuclides by low-energy heavy cosmic rays in molecular clouds. Nature. 368: 222-224.
  5. The nuclear reaction nomenclature (p,d) on a target nucleus, such as 27Al, represents an incident proton picking up a neutron from the target nucleus. The (n, 2n) reaction represents an incident neutron knocking out a neutron from the target nucleus. In both cases the residual nucleus is missing a neutron but remains an isotope of the target nucleus family, i.e., they have the same number of protons.
  6. The abbreviations mb and MeV stand for one millibarn (1 x 10-24 square centimeters) and one million electron volts (1.6022 x 10-13 joules).
  7. The half-life (amount of time for half of the radioactive isotope to decay) of 60Fe is ~1.5 x 106 yrs. A general rule of thumb when measuring radioisotope concentrations is that they become unmeasurable using current technology after about 10 half-lives have passed, i.e., when their concentration is reduced by 210. In the case of 60Fe, that time interval would be ~1.5 x 107 years.

* Dr. Cupps was Research Associate at the Institute for Creation Research and earned his Ph.D. in nuclear physics at Indiana University-Bloomington.

Cite this article: Vernon R. Cupps, Ph.D. 2021. Extinct Radionuclides. Acts & Facts. 50 (4).

The Latest
ACTS & FACTS
Continuous Environmental Tracking : An Engineering-Based Model...
Purpose The Institute for Creation Research is engaged in our biggest science initiative in the last two decades, and it could be our most important...

ACTS & FACTS
CET: Testing the Cavefish Model
Staff Writer Purpose The Institute for Creation Research (ICR) is testing an engineering- based model of rapid biological adaptation called...

ACTS & FACTS
Original Biochemistry in Fossils
Purpose In 1997, paleontologist Dr. Mary Schweitzer accidentally stumbled upon what appeared to be blood vessels and blood cells from a T. rex...

ACTS & FACTS
Debunking an Iconic Uniformitarian Ice Age Theory
Purpose The Milankovitch, or astronomical, theory holds that the timing of Ice Ages is controlled by slow changes in Earth’s orbital and...

ACTS & FACTS
ICR and Explaining the Ice Age
by Larry Vardiman, Ph.D., and Michael J. Oard, M.S.* Purpose There is strong geological evidence for an Ice Age, so the Institute for Creation...

ACTS & FACTS
Planetary Magnetism
Purpose In 1971, Dr. Thomas Barnes publicized a then “trade secret” of scientists studying the earth’s magnetic field, which...

ACTS & FACTS
Cosmology Research
Purpose Taking the Hebrew text of Scripture at face value without inserting gaps or revising the meanings, the universe is only about 6,000 years...

ACTS & FACTS
The Coconino Sandstone: Water, not Wind
Purpose The Coconino Sandstone is one of the most well-known formations in Grand Canyon. The blond-colored sandstone, just three layers down from...

ACTS & FACTS
Global Stratigraphy Supports a Progressive Worldwide Flood
Purpose Is there geological evidence for a global flood? Is there evidence that the waters rose and peaked on Day 150 as recorded in Genesis 8?...

ACTS & FACTS
Human-Chimp DNA Similarity Research Refutes Evolution
Purpose An oft-repeated claim of evolutionary propaganda is that the DNA of chimpanzees and humans is 98.5% identical. This high level of DNA...