Our Day in Court: ICR Graduate School v. THECB et al | The Institute for Creation Research
Our Day in Court: ICR Graduate School v. THECB et al

Longtime Acts & Facts readers will be aware of the Institute for Creation Research's fight for academic freedom in the state of Texas. As prior issues have noted,1 in April 2008 the Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board (THECB) banned the ICR Graduate School (ICRGS) from offering its Master of Science degree in Texas.

In response, ICR filed cases in 2009 to pursue both federal and state law remedies.2 At this point, there are two parallel court proceedings on track for court trials. One is a federal civil rights lawsuit pending in the Western District of Texas, Austin Division. Focusing on government-sponsored "viewpoint discrimination," the suit is currently scheduled for trial in July.

Of course, First Amendment freedoms loom large in this federal civil rights case. Ironically, this case was "removed" from state court (i.e., Travis County District Court), where it was originally filed. It was necessary for that lawsuit to start in Travis County, in order to trigger application of the Texas Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1999, an important Texas law in this controversy. That law provides that if a form of Texas governmental discrimination is based on improper interference with religious liberty, the interference can be remedied by a trial judge, similar to how judges use injunctions to order solutions to other forms of state discrimination (e.g., illegal discrimination based on race, sex, national origin, etc.).

Since the ICRGS Master of Science program (offered in and from California since 1981) focuses on science education rather than "religion," one may ask--why is the Texas Religious Freedom Restoration Act relevant to a lawsuit that is mostly about interference with academic speech (i.e., governmental censorship of academic freedom and free speech as applied to a private school's academic curriculum)?

Although the answer is more complicated than this (due to technicalities of the applicable laws), one of the main issues is this: If the THECB's decision-making process, as shown by the relevant government records, shows that the government officials perceived that they were prohibiting a curriculum because of "religion" (as opposed to "science"), then the officials' conduct is viewed as government interference with religion.

In the federal case, ICRGS has asked for the judge to rule against all of the defendants: the state agency itself (THECB), its commissioner, and those THECB board members who voted to ban ICRGS's degree program from Texas.

The commissioner was deposed in April 2010, and at the time appeared to have difficulty recognizing that the medical MRI invention, used in modern hospitals, was an example of true medical science (perhaps because it illustrates how creationists do "real science").3 During the deposition--which lasted about six hours--the commissioner repeatedly testified that he was not an expert in science and seemed unsure how "science" is defined, yet he nonetheless stuck with his conclusion that ICRGS's science education curriculum (which focuses on geology, biology, and astro/geophysics) was based on "religion," not "science."

The other case, an administrative appeal, is scheduled for trial in late August before an administrative law judge in the Texas State Office of Administrative Hearings. This trial will focus on state law matters, not the THECB's constitutional law violations.

Of course, lawsuits have many "moving parts," so what occurs after this article goes to press cannot be predicted. ICR encourages your prayers that God will be honored,4 justice will be applied, and academic freedom will be safeguarded in and through these upcoming trials.

References

  1. Morris III, H. 2008. Where Has Academic Freedom Gone in Texas? Acts & Facts. 37 (6): 9; Johnson, J. J. S. 2009. Censorship in Texas: Fighting Academic and Religious Discrimination. Acts & Facts. 38 (5): 18.
  2. An administrative appeal petition was previously filed in May 2008.
  3. General Electric Co. v. Fonar Corp. and Damadian, 522 U.S. 908, 118 S.Ct. 266 (1997), denying certiorari to Fonar Corp. and Damadian v. General Electric Co., 107 F.3d 1543, 41 U.S.P.Q.2d 1801 (1997) (reversing JNOV and reinstating a jury verdict of $35,000,000.00 for GE's infringement of inventor Dr. Raymond V. Damadian's medical MRI invention patent).
  4. 1 Corinthians 10:31.

* Dr. Johnson is Special Counsel for the Institute for Creation Research.

Cite this article: Johnson, J. J. S. 2010. Our Day in Court. Acts & Facts. 39 (6): 22.

The Latest
CREATION PODCAST
TThe Secrets of the Cell | The Creation Podcast: Episode 29
Cells are microscopic organisms that are essential to life. What is a cell? What goes on inside of a cell? Did all life come from a single cell? Join...

NEWS
Fossil Footprints Fit Flood Ice-Age Model
Anthropologists Thomas Urban (Cornell University) and Daron Duke (Far Western Anthropological Research Group) recently found preserved human footprints...

NEWS
Deep-Sea Lobster Microbiome
Research continues regarding complex and amazing microbiomes found on or within a variety of creatures.1 The microbiome is a microbial community...

NEWS
"Massively Exciting" Fossil Find
Now this is exciting: “Geologists have found the fossil of the earliest known animal predator. The 560-million-year-old specimen is the first of...

NEWS
Copulation Didn't Kill the Frogs, the Flood Did
Evolutionary scientists recently studied 168 frog fossils from central Germany, concluding that the frogs all drowned while aggressively mating. They claim...

CREATION PODCAST
What Can We Learn From Fossils? | The Creation Podcast: Episode...
Is evolution seen in the fossil record? Why are fossilized terrestrial animals found buried with marine creatures? What conditions were needed to form...

NEWS
Be Not Deceived: Spiritually Train to Overcome Secular Science...
Thorough instruction and discipline are the hallmark qualities of a strong military training program. Well-trained soldiers can think on their feet, adapt...

CREATION.LIVE PODCAST
Jurassic World: Dominion - Fun Movie, Bad Science | Creation.Live...
Covered in feathers, running faster than cars, and living in cold climates...these are just a few of the ideas introduced in Jurassic World: Dominion....

NEWS
CET Model in Plants Is Clearly Seen
Plant scientists have known for decades that plants aren’t just static entities. The half-million or more species of plants in the world display...

NEWS
Half-Billion-Year-Old Fossil Brains?
Once again, a recent and remarkable fossil discovery has been made challenging evolutionary theory. A strange arthropod (i.e. a radiodont) has been found...