Why Do Animals Use Sexual Reproduction?
by Brian Thomas, M.S. | May. 28, 2015
Biologists from the U.K. conducted a 10-year-long experiment on common flour beetles to help understand why insects keep on using sexual reproduction despite its inefficiencies. Though they interpreted the results as supporting evolution, a key observation on the immutability of reproductive systems calls that into question.
In the experiment, European biologists controlled and monitored different beetle populations.1 For each of several generations, 90 males were selected to compete for 10 females in a "strong sexual selection" population.1 But in a second "weak sexual selection" population, the ratio was one-to-one. After many years of these two regimes, offspring from each population were selected for inbreeding.
Inbreeding amplified the mutations that had already accumulated in the two reproducing groups. By seeing how many generations the critters were able to successfully mate in brother and sister pairs before they entered the "extinction vortex," these researchers discerned that the population that had more males than females for many generations staved off mutation-caused extinction much longer than the population where every male beetle could meet and mate with a female.
The team's key question centered on "explanations for the maintenance of costly sexual reproduction," according to Nature.1 Why do animals risk spending so much time and energy on male and female forms and behaviors when "all-female asexual populations would be a far more effective route to reproduce greater numbers of offspring," according to a University of East Anglia press release?2
University of East Anglia biology professor and senior author of the Nature article Matthew Gage revealed the answer, saying, "Our findings provide direct support for the idea that sex persists as a dominant mode of reproduction because it allows sexual selection to provide these important genetic benefits."2
Staving off extinction by somehow minimizing mutational buildup supplied the most important genetic benefit. But does this benefit best explain why "sex persists?" In other words, is there an even better reason why animals—including flour beetles—keep on reproducing sexually?
The researchers did not mention a key observation: No biologist has ever described a natural or man-made process, including "sexual selection" or genetic modification, that reorganized an animal's mode of reproduction. It's far too complicated. Perhaps the reason why these beetles keep on reproducing sexually is not because of the nice benefits of staving off extinction to a future date, but simply because they have no other way to do it! They can only reproduce according to their designed programming.
Reorganizing flour beetles' mode of reproduction would involve altering their instinctual behavior patterns, inventing and integrating new genes, reshaping sexual organs, and networking who-knows-how-many cellular interactions. For example, one team found that several genes involved in making legs and antennae do not contribute to the female flour beetle's main reproductive parts, namely the coxite, stylus and vulva.3 This implies that whole new genes might be necessary for it to reproduce non-sexually.
Plus, whoever or whatever would transform the flour beetle's reproductive system would have to make sure all the new parts worked correctly in just one generation or the insects would simply die off.
The results of this diligently conducted experiment thus may not answer why beetles, and by extension other animals, persist in sexual reproduction. How else are they supposed to reproduce but the way God designed for them? But the results do show a clear benefit to that design—it helps the critters minimize the relentless effects of mutation accumulation in a world that endures its sin-cursed condition.
- Lumley, A. J. et al. Sexual selection protects against extinction. Nature. Published online before print, May 18, 2015, accessed May 18, 2015.
- Population benefits of sexual selection explain the existence of males. University of East Anglia press release. Posted on uea.ac.uk on May 18, 2015, accessed May 18, 2015.
- Aspiras, A. C., F. W. Smith, and D. R. Angelini. 2011. Sex-specific gene interactions in the patterning of insect genitalia. Developmental Biology. 360 (2): 369-380.
*Mr. Thomas is Science Writer at the Institute for Creation Research.
Article posted on May 28, 2015.
The Good Pastor
Nine Forty-Day Periods
Remembering Mount St. Helens 35 Years Later
A landslide on the northern side of Mount St. Helens in Washington state on May 18, 1980 uncorked a violent volcanic eruption of ash, vapor, molten material and pulverized rock. The effects of this one of the most scrupulously documented volcanos in history have reshaped the way geologists think about certain landforms. More...
The Pillar and Ground of the Truth
“These things write I unto thee, hoping to come into thee shortly: But if I tarry long, that thou mayest know how thou oughtest to behave thyself in the house of God, which is the church of the living God, the pillar and ground of the truth.” (1 Timothy 3:14-15) More...
- Pilgrims on the Earth
- A Provoked Spirit
- The Veil over the Nations
- What Mean These Stones
- The Victor's Crown
- Our Sins in His Body
- The Righteous Man
- New Fossil Dubbed 'Platypus Dinosaur'
- Afraid to Understand
- A Righteous Heart
- The Witness of Creation
- Ascending Vapors
- The Tongue of the Learned
- Clever Construction in Rorqual Whales